Always able to get in and out in a timely manner during lunch. The pizza is good especially for the price of a the buffet. They are always putting fresh pizzas. Highly recommended for lunch.

Amazing deal

Love this place absolute 🔥

Fat Jimmy’s Pizza12216 Shelbyville Rd.Louisville, KY 402434/09/2024Our Homeowner’s Association went to Middletown’s Fat Jimmy’s Pizza Co. 17 of our residents were anxious to get to Fat Jimmy's Pizza Buffet. There was about 7 different kinds of pizza on the buffet or you could build your own pizza. There was also a salad bar that had about 16 ingredients to add to your salads. Some ordered thin crust pizzas and there was a Pepperoni Pizza with Jalapeños on my table.I ordered a Ham and Cheese Calzone that was as big as your head! It was delicious and lasted til the next day for our lunch.We really had a great time. Talking with our neighbors and sharing pizzas across the tables. There were desserts and breads, too.Emma was great setting up our tables before everyone got there. Emma was so great at keeping our tables bussed so we could go back and get new plates of pizza. The pizzas just kept coming out from the ovens and it was a really enjoyable time.